Friday, February 28, 2020

Judge on Cosby trial ordered assessment that was recently deemed ‘unconstitutional’ by higher-court

• Cosby judge ordered evaluation despite higher court's recent opinion calling it 'unconstitutional.'
• Bill Cosby was ordered to undergo an assessment that was recently deemed 'unconstitutional' by Pa. Superior Court.
• Sources believe the assessment is a 'publicity stunt.'

Bill Cosby found himself back on prime-time television when millions around the world turned to the news as the verdict was announced in what experts label the highest watched trial of modern-times. Just as reporters fled the courtroom to announce that the comic icon was found guilty — Judge Steven T. O’Neill made a move that was recently deemed ‘unconstitutional’ and ‘illegal’ by the Pennsylvania Superior Court — and sources confirm it was a “publicity-driven” decision!

Immediately following the guilty verdict, Bill Cosby was ordered to undergo a Sexually Violent Predator Assessment as part of his release conditions — an evaluation that would’ve been typical practice if he was found guilty at his original trial — but in November, the Pennsylvania Superior Court found the assessment was ‘unconstitutional’ and a waste of taxpayer money and time.

“Accordingly, we are constrained to hold that [Sexually Violent Predator Assessments] [are] unconstitutional,” the Pa. Superior Court wrote in their decision in Com. v. Butler, adding it was “illegal” to order Butler to partake in the assessment.

The decision came in November 2017, just months after the initial trial and prior to the retrial.

The amended law governing the classification of sexually violent predators states that “the court shall determine whether the Commonwealth has proved by clear and convincing evidence that the individual is a sexually violent predator.” Therefore, the burden to determine whether or not Bill Cosby fits the profile rested on the prosecution.

The Butler Court held that the assessment is a form of illegal-punishment because the court did not make its determination based on the highest standard of proof: beyond a reasonable doubt and because the statute allows the judge to make the determination instead of giving the defendant the right to a jury, Philadelphia based criminal defense attorney Zak T. Goldstein told our reporters.

Another lawyer would only comment under the circumstance of anonymity as he practices in Montgomery County, strongly believes [Judge] O’Neill’s ruling was solely focused on publicity.

“Basically, our higher-courts deemed the assessment so useless that it was unconstitutional – the only purpose for it is to drag a defendant through the mud and in this case it’s Cosby,” he continued.

This evaluation will buy them more primetime television,” the source continued, referring to Montgomery County District Attorney Kevin Steele.

“It was unconstitutional to require someone to register as an SVP [Sexual Violent Predator] unless a jury found that the person was an SVP beyond a reasonable doubt,” Goldstein told our reporters, referring to the Butler decision.

Just last week Lancaster County Judge Jeffrey Wright ordered a background check and general evaluation on 33-year-old Rafael Saez who was found guilty of sexually abusing a pre-teen girl. The judge in that recent trial did not order a specific evaluation that determines if Saez is deemed a “sexually violent predator.”

Sources who reside in Montgomery County believe the assessment is a tactic to bring the media back for an additional hearing on the assessment.

- Advertisement -


How the coronavirus spreads from person-to-person

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) likely spreads from animal to person, though person-to-person transmission occurs through respiratory droplets.

Cured coronavirus patient gives update and dances to ‘I’ve had the time of my life’

British man who was cured from the coronavirus was filmed dancing to 'I've had the time of my life' following his release from the bug-ridden cruise liner.

California declares state of emergency as coronavirus infestation spreads

California has declared a state of emergency following the deadly coronavirus infestation that is uncontrollably spreading throughout the state.

MillerCoors gunman identified as Anthony Ferrill, 51, who shot and killed 5 colleagues

The gunman who killed five co-workers and then took his own life at Milwaukee's MillerCoors complex had worked there for 17 years.
- Advertisement -

California declares state of emergency as coronavirus infestation spreads

California has declared a state of emergency following the deadly coronavirus infestation that is uncontrollably spreading throughout the state.

Quaden Bayles declines money for trip to Disneyland, all funds to go to charity

Quaden Bayles's family have decided to turn down the free trip to Disneyland, and all the money raised will go to charity, Your Content has learned.

Cops uncover treasure-trove after dimwits continue zipping by despite police presence

Police in Newtown Square are cashing in as a result of dimwit drivers who continue to blatantly ignore their speed trap that is going on 3 months.

Witness that testified against Harvey Weinstein at rape trial run over by car in Philly

Dr. Barbara Ziv testified for the prosecution at the Weinstein trial but run down by a crazed Philly driver shortly after.

Police & FBI swarm MillerCoors in Milwaukee for reports of an ‘active shooting’

Police are responding to reports of an active shooting at the MillerCoors headquarters in Milwaukee.
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you