MOSCOW, Idaho — The high-profile trial of accused serial killer Bryan Kohberger has entered contentious territory as disagreements over grand jury transcripts and records arise between the defense and prosecution, Your Content has learned.
A court document released today indicates that Kohberger’s defense counsel and the State have failed to agree on the terms of an initial proposed stipulation concerning the “Order for Preparation and Release of Transcript and Record of Grand Jury Proceedings with Conditions.” This disagreement has prompted the State to submit a detailed consideration to the court.
Kohberger’s defense had sought to make available the record of all proceedings of the grand jury, a move that the State has argued is beyond what is permitted by law. In addition, the defense suggested unsealing various grand jury proceedings subject to a later “qualified protective order,” a proposal at odds with the rule requiring the grand jury records and transcript to remain sealed.
Despite this disagreement, both parties may be allowed access to listen to the audio record and a transcript of grand jury proceedings.
According to the court document, further disclosures from grand jury proceedings beyond the audio recording/transcript and the list of jurors can only occur by order of the Court “for good cause shown.” The State maintains that the defense has not demonstrated a valid reason for the detailed list of items they requested in their motion.
The State’s submission suggests that the Court should order the preparation and release of a transcript of the grand jury proceedings (excluding deliberations) for the State and defense to review confidentially. The State also agreed to the list of jurors’ notes being disclosed to counsel.
Once the transcript and audio recording are reviewed by both parties, the Court will determine whether there is a “good cause” as required law.
This legal squabble adds another layer of complexity to an already convoluted case, which has captured the public’s attention. Kohberger is accused of multiple murders, the gravity of which has made this case one of the most prominent in Idaho’s recent history.
Kohberger, who was indicted last month on charges of four counts of first-degree murder and one count of burglary, made headlines after the horrific crime in November 2022. The crime scene was a gruesome tableau at an off-campus home where four University of Idaho students: Ethan Chapin, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Kaylee Goncalves, were found stabbed to death.
After a six-week-long probe, investigators tracked down Kohberger’s white Hyundai Elantra, analyzed cell phone signal data, and retrieved his DNA from a knife sheath found near one of the victims’ bodies. This trail of evidence led to Kohberger’s arrest on December 30 in Pennsylvania, where he had driven cross-country to spend the holidays at his family home in Albrightsville.
Even though the actual murder weapon has not been found, investigators have launched an intensive examination of Kohberger’s online presence, which extends to several platforms such as Reddit, Google, TikTok, and Snapchat. Search warrant applications have been issued to scrutinize these accounts, as well as the Snapchat accounts of the four victims. Investigators are also studying additional records from AT&T.
The investigation into Kohberger’s online activity has yielded significant findings. From his Reddit account, authorities have retrieved public posts, private messages, saved files, photos, and location data. One notable post included a survey posted by Kohberger on understanding the influence of emotions and psychological traits on decision-making during criminal activities.
Investigators also acquired comprehensive records from Kohberger’s Google account, including his emails, hangouts and chats with photos, documents on Google Drive, and associated metadata. The warrant has also granted access to his search and browsing history, calendar events, contacts, Google Play purchases, and Google Pay transactions.
AT&T records have also been collected for an unknown subscriber during the period of June 23, 2022, to August 1, 2022. These records include messages, files, logs, deleted information, and cell tower pings related to incoming and outgoing calls. These cell tower records were pivotal in connecting Kohberger to the crime scene.
Investigators have also sought data from the internet service “Strava,” which users utilize to track physical exercise and share performance on social networks. This data includes exercise data, session logs, geolocation data, contacts, and photos.
Furthermore, Snapchat records associated with the four victims were also procured. These records encompass communications, messages, logs of previous snaps, stories, chats, and all correspondence between Snapchat and the users.
This developing story has ignited public attention as the case is scheduled to go to trial on October 2. As the legal wrangling around the grand jury proceedings continues, the implications of these digital breadcrumbs are being carefully dissected to illuminate the circumstances surrounding this chilling case.